This article is part of a series sponsored by Amwins.
The healthcare industry continues to navigate a complex risk landscape. Rising claims severity, social inflation, workforce challenges and ongoing regulatory pressures are among the biggest challenges currently facing the healthcare market.
While market conditions have stabilized in some segments due to increased carrier participation and the addition of new capacity, underlying loss trends continue to impact underwriting strategies, pricing and coverage. Organizations across healthcare are also adapting to emerging risks related to technology adoption, artificial intelligence and changing care delivery models.
Healthcare buyers face a market rife with opportunity and uncertainty as insurers balance growth goals with deteriorating claims experiences. Understanding the unique dynamics affecting each sector remains critical to ensuring appropriate coverage.
Elder care
This market segment is becoming an increasingly litigious environment. California, Florida, New York and other historically litigious states continue to face coverage challenges, placing greater scrutiny on sites experiencing nuclear adjudication activity.
Claim frequency and severity continue to trend upward, driven by social inflation and rising defense costs. However, while established carriers continue to seek adequate rates to cope with worsening loss trends and reserve pressures, a significant amount of new market capacity has entered the space. This has resulted in intense competition and continued weak market conditions, despite potential claims challenges.
Capacity remains widely available for primary placements, with numerous operators actively competing for business. Excess markets, on the other hand, take a more cautious approach when challenging jurisdictions that typically offer lower limits, require higher attachment points or limit participation by new entrants.
Coverage considerations remain a key focus. Senior housing accounts are increasingly experiencing challenges related to emergency response and roping risks because some carriers view these risks as professional liability risks rather than general liability risks.
Insurance coverage responses vary widely, so policy form analysis is critical. Additionally, some carriers are introducing abuse and harassment coverage limits, including excess exclusions or secondary limits on primary policies.
Operating pressures on aged care providers remain. Many facilities continue to operate at reduced staffing levels amid ongoing workforce shortages, while Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement pressures create budget constraints. Even as facilities begin to adopt new technologies and AI-driven tools to support resident care and operations, adequate staffing remains critical to effectively respond to alerts, advisories, and resident needs.
Looking ahead, as claims trends continue to worsen, risk management practices and experienced claims handling will remain key differentiators. Retailers should carefully evaluate a carrier’s commitment, financial stability and long-term experience in the segment, as new entrants offering aggressive pricing may provide short-term relief but have yet to demonstrate performance throughout the claims cycle. As the industry continues to contend with rising loss costs and litigation pressures, established carriers with proven claims expertise and long-term market commitment may provide greater stability.
human and social services
The human and social services sector remains one of the most challenging areas of healthcare responsibility, although market conditions have become more manageable compared to recent years as new E&S operators introduce additional capacity and competition.
Placements involving youth-focused organizations, foster care, behavioral health and residential services continue to face rigorous underwriting scrutiny due to long-tail liability risks. Sexual abuse and harassment (SAM) claims and evolving statutes of limitations legislation are allowing historical sexual abuse claims to resurface decades later.
Recognized carriers continue to reduce capacity, significantly increase rates, and bring more risk into the E&S market. While E&S renewal rate changes are generally more modest, the umbrella and excess liability capabilities for accounts involving youth transportation, developmental disabilities services, and complex abuse risks remain limited, often requiring layered structures and creative plan design.
There are also more E&S markets willing to assess these risks on a case-by-case basis, providing insureds with more options. While the pricing differences between packages and E&S placements are still wide, there are more viable coverage avenues than in previous years.
Coverage restrictions around SAM, HNOA, transportation risk and retroactive coverage continue to evolve as carriers reassess risks in the industry. At the same time, inflation, staffing shortages, and reduced government funding have forced many organizations to lower limits, increase retention, or expand into unfamiliar service offerings, creating additional underwriting issues.
Technology and artificial intelligence are also becoming increasingly prevalent in behavioral health and social services organizations, particularly with regard to documentation, compliance, and resource allocation. While some carriers are positive about responsible AI implementation, others are introducing additional underwriting scrutiny and AI-related underwriting restrictions.
In this environment, early engagement and detailed underwriting submissions remain critical to a successful placement. Retailers and insureds who initiate renewals 90 to 120 days in advance and work with experienced health care and social services experts are best positioned to achieve favorable outcomes in an increasingly complex market.
life sciences
The life sciences industry remains generally stable, with adequate capabilities across many product-focused and casualty-driven risks. Despite increased underwriting scrutiny of organizations integrating health care services, providers and emerging technologies into their operations, increased carrier participation and new market entrants have created a competitive environment for the lower-risk category.
Accounts involving direct-to-patient services, clinical trials, telemedicine and provider-intensive operations are receiving increasing attention from carriers, particularly with regard to excess liability placements. While key pricing remains relatively stable, the glut market continues to see modest rate hikes and cautious deployment of capacity to address more complex healthcare-related risks. Certain categories, including spinal devices, surgical mesh and pharmaceuticals, are also facing increased underwriting pressure due to severity concerns and changing litigation trends.
AI-driven diagnostics, genetic testing and technology-enabled patient care remain key areas of focus for the industry. As artificial intelligence becomes increasingly integrated into clinical trials, treatment support and patient care, operators are increasingly focusing on technology governance, clinical oversight and risk management protocols.
Coverage structures have also become more nuanced, particularly where organizations maintain separate network, technology E&O, and malpractice towers, which can create potential coverage gaps for technology-related physical injury claims.
Regulatory complexities continue to increase for organizations that operate across multiple states or utilize affiliated healthcare providers, particularly as direct-to-patient healthcare models expand. As these risks evolve, experienced healthcare and life sciences experts remain critical to navigating increasingly complex underwriting structures and emerging technology risks.
UnitedHealth
The market in this segment remains stable as competition intensifies with the entry of new operators. Increased capacity continues to drive down rates as competition for business in new and existing markets increases. Still, challenges remain in high-risk categories such as correctional healthcare, behavioral health and social services, where increased claim frequency and severity limits carrier appetite.
There has also been increased scrutiny of coverage, particularly with regard to sexual abuse and harassment and leased and non-owned cars, which are now more aggressively underwritten and priced. These coverages may be more difficult to secure within redundant layers and umbrellas, and operators are also looking to limit capacity and reduce exposure.
Hospital
Within the hospital industry, liability conditions continue to worsen as operators contend with worsening loss trends. While capacity remains available, many markets are reducing line sizes, adding connection points and tightening terms, especially for large healthcare systems. Excess pricing has risen sharply amid greater scrutiny of reports of sexual abuse and harassment and reduced senior-level involvement.
These shifts are primarily due to rising claims severity due to nuclear awards, despite a downward trend in claim frequency. Challenging areas such as Cook County, New York boroughs, New Mexico and parts of the Southeast remain key areas of concern, with litigation pressure showing few signs of easing. Additionally, uncertainty over tort reform, including the potential increase in malpractice caps, continues to weigh on the field.
takeout
Across the healthcare industry, increased market competition and increased capacity have created opportunities for many insureds, especially in primary liability placements. However, rising claim frequency and severity, social inflation, litigation pressures and operational challenges continue to impact carrier interest and underwriting discipline. As a result, favorable pricing conditions don’t always translate into long-term stability or broader coverage.
In this market, organizations should focus beyond premium savings and carefully evaluate carrier commitment, financial strength, claims expertise and underwriting structure. Early renewal planning, strong risk management practices and collaboration with dedicated health insurance professionals remain critical to navigating an increasingly complex market.
We help you win
Amwins mobilizes hundreds of health insurance professionals across the country to provide property, casualty, specialty and group benefits insurance to a variety of classes and employer groups.
Through our long-term commitment to the healthcare industry, we have developed valuable relationships with top professional operators and developed exclusive products that meet our customers’ unique needs. Amwins partners with you to ensure the most comprehensive, competitive coverage for your healthcare customers.
Insights provided by:
- Joe Carlson, Executive Vice President, Amwins Brokerage
- Jordan Connelly, Executive Vice President, Amwins Brokerage
- Amanda Fioretti, Senior Vice President, Program Underwriters, Amwins
- Ryan Gillispie, Executive Vice President, Amwins Brokerage
- Gerald Helfrich, Executive Vice President, Amwins Brokerage
- Dylan Jordan, Senior Vice President, Amwins Agency
- Megan Kramer, Senior Vice President, Amwins Agency
- Dave Statis, executive vice president, Amwins Brokerage
- Don Tejeski, Executive Vice President, Amwins Brokerage
- Matt Wasta, Executive Vice President, Program Underwriters, Amwins
